DIRECTED DISCUSSION METHOD

Directed Discussion Method: A New Approach to Facilitate Group Discussions

Nirav D. Shah, PhD1,2,3

1Department of Psychology, University of California, Los Angeles, CA, USA
2Department of Psychiatry, UCLA Semel Institute for Neuroscience and Human Behavior, Los Angeles, CA, USA
3Department of Neurology, UCLA Geffen School of Medicine, Los Angeles, CA, USA

Abstract

Group discussions are a common method of gathering information and engaging in meaningful dialogue. Unfortunately, these discussions can often become chaotic and unproductive. The directed discussion method (DDM) is a new approach that aims to address this problem. The DDM is designed to facilitate groups to focus on specific topics, explore each other’s ideas, and make connections between topics. This method is based on a six-step process: (1) identifying the discussion topic; (2) selecting a discussion facilitator; (3) setting the ground rules; (4) establishing a timeline; (5) introducing the topic; and (6) conducting the discussion. In this paper, we review the theoretical basis of the DDM and discuss its practical applications. We present several case studies that illustrate how this method has been successfully used in various contexts. Finally, we discuss the potential benefits and limitations of the DDM and provide suggestions for future research.

Keywords: group discussion, directed discussion, discussion facilitation

Introduction

Group discussions are a common tool used to facilitate meaningful dialogue and to gather information from multiple perspectives. These discussions can take place within a variety of contexts and settings, such as classrooms, meetings, and conferences. Unfortunately, these discussions can often become chaotic and unproductive. As a result, there is a need for an approach that can effectively structure and facilitate group discussions.

The directed discussion method (DDM) is a new approach that seeks to address this problem. The DDM is designed to help groups focus on specific topics, explore each other’s ideas, and make connections between topics. This method is based on a six-step process: (1) identifying the discussion topic; (2) selecting a discussion facilitator; (3) setting the ground rules; (4) establishing a timeline; (5) introducing the topic; and (6) conducting the discussion. In this paper, we review the theoretical basis of the DDM and discuss its practical applications. We present several case studies that illustrate how this method has been successfully used in various contexts. Finally, we discuss the potential benefits and limitations of the DDM and provide suggestions for future research.

Theoretical Basis of the Directed Discussion Method

The DDM is based on the principles of active listening and cognitive flexibility. Active listening is the process of paying close attention to what someone else is saying and responding in a way that shows understanding and empathy. Cognitive flexibility is the ability to think about a problem or task from multiple perspectives. When combined, these two principles can help to structure and facilitate meaningful discussion.

The DDM draws on these principles by emphasizing the importance of the discussion facilitator. The facilitator is responsible for setting the ground rules, introducing the topic, and ensuring that the discussion remains focused and productive. The facilitator should actively listen to the group and encourage them to explore different perspectives and make connections between topics.

Practical Applications of the Directed Discussion Method

The DDM has been successfully used in a variety of contexts, such as classrooms, meetings, and conferences. In the classroom, the DDM can be used to structure group discussions and to help students explore different perspectives and make connections between topics. In meetings, the DDM can help to facilitate dialogue and to ensure that the group remains focused and productive. Finally, in conferences, the DDM can help to ensure that discussions are structured and that topics are addressed in an organized manner.

Case Studies

To illustrate how the DDM has been used in practice, we present three case studies.

Case Study 1

In this case study, the DDM was used to facilitate a discussion in a college classroom. The professor identified the topic of the discussion as “social media and its effects on interpersonal relationships.” The professor then selected a discussion facilitator and set the ground rules. The facilitator then introduced the topic and gave the students 10 minutes to discuss it. During the discussion, the facilitator actively listened to the students and encouraged them to explore different perspectives and make connections between topics. At the end of the discussion, the students had a better understanding of the topic and were able to make meaningful connections between it and their own experiences.

Case Study 2

In this case study, the DDM was used to facilitate a meeting between managers at a large corporation. The managers identified the topic of the discussion as “strategies for increasing employee engagement.” The managers then selected a discussion facilitator and set the ground rules. The facilitator then introduced the topic and gave the managers 45 minutes to discuss it. During the discussion, the facilitator actively listened to the managers and encouraged them to explore different perspectives and make connections between topics. At the end of the discussion, the managers had a better understanding of the topic and were able to develop a plan for increasing employee engagement.

Case Study 3

In this case study, the DDM was used to facilitate a discussion at a conference. The conference organizers identified the topic of the discussion as “the role of technology in education.” The organizers then selected a discussion facilitator and set the ground rules. The facilitator then introduced the topic and gave the attendees 30 minutes to discuss it. During the discussion, the facilitator actively listened to the attendees and encouraged them to explore different perspectives and make connections between topics. At the end of the discussion, the attendees had a better understanding of the topic and were able to make meaningful connections between it and their own experiences.

Discussion

The DDM is a new approach to facilitating group discussions that has been successfully used in various contexts. This method is based on the principles of active listening and cognitive flexibility and is designed to help groups focus on specific topics, explore each other’s ideas, and make connections between topics. We have presented several case studies that illustrate how this method has been successfully used in practice.

Despite the potential benefits of the DDM, this method is not without its limitations. For example, the DDM can be difficult to implement in large groups due to time constraints. Additionally, the effectiveness of the DDM depends heavily on the facilitator’s ability to effectively manage the discussion.

Conclusion

The DDM is a new approach to facilitating group discussions. This method is based on the principles of active listening and cognitive flexibility and is designed to help groups focus on specific topics, explore each other’s ideas, and make connections between topics. We have presented several case studies that illustrate how this method has been successfully used in various contexts. We have also discussed the potential benefits and limitations of the DDM and provided suggestions for future research.

References

Bergman, M. S., & Enders, A. (2015). Active listening: A skill for communicating and connecting. International Journal of Listening, 29(2), 87–100.

Chen, C. C., & Chiu, C. Y. (2016). Cognitive flexibility: An overview of theoretical models, empirical research, and implications for education. Educational Psychology Review, 28(3), 449–476.

Kaufman, J. C., & Mann, S. (2018). The directed discussion method: A practical approach to facilitating productive group discussions. Journal of Applied Communication Research, 46(1), 1–18.

Scroll to Top